
Executive Summary
An approximately 32,000 acre earthen embankment reservoir with a
maximum normal pool storage depth of 12-feet;
An approximately 32,000 acre roller compacted concrete embankment
reservoir with a maximum normal pool storage depth of 12-feet; and
An approximately 26,500 acre earthen embankment reservoir with a
maximum normal pool storage depth of 14-feet.
In addition, conveyance improvements to the following existing canals were
included in each of the alternative plans: Miami Canal, North New River Canal,
and Bolles and Cross Canals.
The alternative plans were compared using a system formulation and evaluation
approach to identify the alternative plan that maximizes net system-wide
benefits of the comprehensive plan. This was accomplished by evaluating
environmental benefits (habitat units) for the Caloosahatchee and St. Lucie
Estuaries, Lake Okeechobee, and the Everglades Protection Area as part of a
system formulation and evaluation analysis (i.e., the alternative plan plus all of
the other projects in the CERP compared to the future without-project
condition). An incremental analysis was also performed as part of the system-
wide evaluation. A next-added incremental justification analysis was also
performed to determine if the benefits attributable to the selected plan are
sufficient to justify its cost as a stand-alone project (if no additional CERP
projects are built). The State of Florida's "Everglades Agricultural Area A-1
Project" being implemented through its "Acceler8" program is similar to the Cell
1 component of the selected plan, and was therefore evaluated as an increment
of the selected plan during the plan formulation and evaluation conducted for
this project.
SELECTED PLAN ELEMENTS
The selected plan, Alternative 4, features an approximately 31,000-acre above-
ground reservoir impoundment with earthen embankments and a maximum
normal pool storage depth of twelve feet. The reservoir is divided into two cells,
Cell 1 and Cell 2, approximately 17,000 and 14,000 acres in size, respectively.
Both reservoir cells include individual inflow pump stations, discharge
structures, emergency overflow spillways, and seepage control canals with
associated structures. Total acreage required for the selected plan is estimated
to be 31,640 acres (including the area of the seepage canals to the south and
west of the reservoir). A stormwater treatment area comprised of approximately
1,495 acres is proposed east of the Miami Canal and west of the reservoir. The
layout of the selected plan is depicted in
Figure 2.
EAA Storage Reservoirs Revised Draft PIR and EIS February 2006
ES-v
Comentários a estes Manuais